Andre loez in an eyeopening lecture as he addresses how the mutinies. Women and the french army during the world wars, 19141940. Three were acquitted, eight sentenced to five years penal servitude and the rest two years imprisonment. Just been browsing hew strachans excellent short history the first world war, and on page 269 he says that the bold highlights are my own. However, within the hierarchy of the army, many senior. That is to say, historians have focused their attention on how national politics has influenced the military efficiency of the french army of august 1914. During the years which followed the francoprussian war of 18701 a war for the reconquest of alsace and lorraine was very frequently discussed in france.
Witness history, the french army mutiny of 1917 bbc world service. The mutinies threatened to paralyseq the allied war effort on the western front, forcing the british expeditionary force and belgian army to assume larger roles. One hundred years after french mutineers shouted, down with the war. The mutinies originate with french soldiers at the front, but quickly spread to the civilian population of northern france. The army of 1917, with its mutinies during the wastefully inept and. Enhanced by wellchosen photographs, detailed tables, and a helpful, concise bibliographic essay, it is essential reading for all students of the french military, world war i, and military history in general. Churchill himself condemned the conduct of the court martial in the commons. In the spring of 1917, the french army faced a stern test widespread mutiny. Although fighting occurred worldwide, the bulk of the fighting in europe occurred in belgium, luxembourg, france and alsacelorraine along what came to be known as the western front, which consisted mainly of trench warfare. In may 1946, at the muar camp in malaya, over 250 privates refused to obey orders and were later charged with mutiny.
French soldier with pipe resting after world war i battle. The hidden story of soldiers mutinies, strikes and. French military doctrine between the world wars no. The french and british army mutinies of 191719 november 3, 2017 by craig dilouie 2 comments in 191719, as the first world war was coming to a close and afterwards, the french and british armies were reeling as thousands of soldiers mutinied. The historiographical literature on the french army before world war i has. The french army mutiny of 1917 witness history in the spring of 1917, many french army units mutinied after enduring years of slaughter and appalling conditions during world war one. Meyer pyrrhic victory by robert doughty breaking point of the french army.
The nivelle offensive of 1917 by david murphy between mutiny and obedience by leonard v. Why did french soldiers mutiny during ww1 while other. They started just after the disastrous second battle of the aisne, the main action in the nivelle offensive in april 1917. How did mutinies affect the french and russian army. On april 16, 1917, french general robert nivelle, newlyappointed as commander of the french army, thought he was about to win the first world war. Most these troops were deployed inside france with the bulk along the eastern frontier as part of plan 17.
Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. A heavily guarded secret at the time, it is now widely known that the french army was partly neutralised by mutinies in the summer of 1917. Sage business cases realworld cases at your fingertips opens in new tab. Acts of defiance a short history of mutiny in the u. On may 3, 1917, french troops in some of the regiments that had suffered the greatest casualties in commander in chief robert nivelles chemin des dames offensive mutinied, with actions that spread to 16 army corps in four armies, and led to civilian sympathy strikes. The official 100th anniversary commemorations of world war one ww1 mostly record a honourable, noble cause fought by happy, loyal, patriotic soldiers.
World war i wikibooks, open books for an open world. The case of the french fifth infantry division during world war. In 1919, britain came close to a workers and soldiers uprising. Ethan rafuse, a professor of history at cgsc, presented the french mutinies in the arnold conference room of the lewis and clark center on fort leavenworth, may 3, at 6 p. Evolution of french infantry during world war 1 i the. But it was not the same in the french army, where in general, conditions were worse than they were for the british and in 1917, after three years of total war. Some of the accused privates of the th battalion parachute regiment in the muar mutiny case. Pershing great war centennial series intended to educate the public about world war. The historiographical literature on the french army before world war i has adopted wholeheartedly clausewitzs dictum that politics determines war, essentially as clausewitz understood it. Also the combat tactics evolved considerably in four years of war. The true story of the french army mutinies of 1917.
This episode is related to military discipline and world war i. The third republic, the war and the mutiny in the french. General robert nivelle had promised a decisive warending victory over the germans in 48 hours. The third republic, the war and the mutiny in the french army in 1917. Andrew orrs women and the french army during the world wars adds further nuance to existing debates about the nature of womens participation in military affairs in the first half of the twentieth century.
The french army and the first world war ebook written by elizabeth greenhalgh. This committee secured the support of the local french civilian population, including the railway workers. This article is about the french army in world war i. The first article looks at the french army mutinies in world war i and how the french army dealt with them. View or download all content the institution has subscribed to. Bbc radio 4 voices of the first world war, french mutinies. French army and the first world war in january 1914 the french army had 47 divisions 777,000 french and 46,000 colonial troops in 21 regional corps, with attached cavalry and fieldartillery units. Im assuming youre referring to mutinies by soldiers that occurred during the great war, which later became known as world war i.
A number of american military mutinies have stemmed from racial unrest. Mutiny and resistance in the royal navy, 19181930 dave lamb. Modern historians, with full access to the records, characterize the mutinies of 1917 more as mass actions rather than rebellions. Pages in category mutinies the following 141 pages are in this category, out of 141 total. Whilst the mutinies in the german and french navies in the first world war have been well documented little information is. The french army mutinies of 1917 took place amongst the french troops on the western front in northern france during world war i.
The french military had to quickly find a way to discipline tens of thousands of soldiers and also persuade them to fight. It was an intolerable defeat for an army that had registered few victories during the war, nivelle lost his command on 15 th may and the french were left in a state of abject despair. For example, an armed rebellion by 156 black soldiers in houston erupted in november of 1917 after civilian police viciously beat an african american infantryman in the streets of the city. It grows and expands to become known as the mutinies of 1917. According to eyewitnesses, the soldier was attacked while trying to prevent the officers from assaulting a civilian. French army and the first world war spartacus educational. State, society and mobilization in europe during the first world war edited by john horne july 1997. The true story of the french army mutinies of 1917 barnes and noble. French army in world war i faced the most formidable german military forces. In 1954, the french army was recovering from the catastrophic defeat in the colonial war in indochina.
The french army and the first world war by elizabeth. David murphys study is the first fulllength account in english to analyze in detail the reasons for the failure of the nivelle offensive and the implications for the future. Rafuses lecture was the 11th of the general of the armies john j. This patch will update your copy of strategic command to v1. Responding in large part to the argument advanced by margaret and patrice higonnet, among others, that womens gains in the world wars were not accompanied by longterm, sustained. French army mutinies topic of great war lecture command. In the spring of 1917, many french army units mutinied after enduring years of slaughter and appalling conditions during world war one. Remobilizing the citizensoldier through the french army mutinies of. A short history of mutinies and rebellions in the british royal navy and marines from the end of world war i, russian revolution and up until 1930. The french soldier in 1914 was already very different from the one in 1918 if you looked at his uniform or equipment. Media in category french army mutinies 1917 this category contains only the following file. Bria 17 3 a the french army mutinies of world war i.
They started just after the unsuccessful and costly second battle of the aisne, the main action in the nivelle offensive in april 1917. General robert nivelle had promised a decisive war ending victory over the germans in 48 hours. It effectively destroyed french army morale, leading to a series of troop mutinies and the will of the french politicians and people to continue the war was undermined. This issue of bill of rights in action explores questions of military authority. Dan snow presents the story of wwi through the voices of those who were there. During world war i, france was one of the triple entente powers allied against the central powers. The poilus had had enough of terrible conditions, little or no home leave and incompetent, unrealistic leadership. The army supported the fatherland party through its own press agency and through the censorship of the. The mutiny in the french army was successfully hushed up and when writing after world war one, luderndorff stated that he knew nothing about what was happening within the french army. Constitutional rights foundation bill of right in action summer 2001 17.
British and indian mutinies post wwii weapons and warfare. Mutinies remembrance trails of the great war in northern. But its not a story the official ww1 commemoration wants to highlight. Unit swapping, adjacent units can now have their positions easily swapped with a new in game swapping mechanism. Few of those executed were mutineers in the proper sense of the word. But the best thing is the ample historical background provided by the author regarding the political, emotional and military situation in france before and during the first years of the war that defined what happened later in the mutinies. Air command and staff college abstract the traditional images of the french army in world war i on the western front from cyril fallss to marc ferros surveys both entitled the great war 1914 1918 have been that of the grizzled yet determined french peasant or worker the poilu. I unhappily presided over the army when there was a shoal of mutinies, and no one ever attempted to bring large masses of the rank and file to a mass trial. Choose your file higher quality 128kbps lower quality 64kbps. The second article examines president trumans firing of popular and powerful general douglas macarthur during the korean war. General philippe petain understands better than nivelle how to end the mutinies. The 1917 french army mutinies took place amongst french army troops on the western front in northern france during world war i. The german army had 11 million under arms, the ottoman empire had 2.
446 1018 491 230 310 865 657 1247 1162 777 1478 1005 370 798 385 1358 607 1343 328 120 1283 1557 1020 973 11 329 1017 685 501 381 107 317 1275 734 1178 150 600 708 840 1227 1267 1085 277 496 127